doi: 10.5862/MCE.39.4

Application of modified yield criteria for calculation of safe pressures on the subgrade soil

A.L. Kalinin, Siberian State Automobile and Highway Academy, Omsk, Russia

The article deals with design the road constructions by ensuring the shear resistance of the subgrade soil and pavement layers made of weakly cohesive materials. 

The analysis of Mohr–Coulomb plasticity criterion was performed and it was found, that in case of a limiting condition state by this criterion pavement smoothness goes out of the limits regulated by normative documents. On the basis of analysis of Drucker-–Prager yield criterion there were obtained formulas connecting ultimate strength uniaxial compression and tension with the parameters of Mohr-Coulomb failure envelope. Substitution of these expressions into the original criteria for the strength of materials, that are continuums, allowed modifying certain conditions so that the tensile strength changed the angle of internal friction and cohesion. 

A number of dependencies for calculating safe pressure on discrete material of half-space is obtained from the modified conditions of plasticity. Comparison of the numerical results to experimental data allowed determining the most suitable formula for the design of road constructions.

Key words:

yield criteria; principal stresses; safe pressure

Read the whole article (rus) in pdf

(Kalinin A.L. Primeneniye modifitsirovannykh usloviy plastichnosti dlya rascheta bezopasnykh davleniy na grunty zemlyanogo polotna [Application of modified yield criteria for calculation of safe pressures on the subgrade soil]. Magazine of Civil Engineering. 2013. No.4(39). Pp. 35–45).


1. Aleksandrov A.S. Structural Mechanics of Engineering Constructions and Buildings. 2009. No.2. Pp. 3–11. (rus)

2. Zhustareva E.V. Vliyanie plotnosti sviaznogo grunta v rabochem sloye zemlyanogo polotna na ostatochnyye deformatsii nezhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [The impact of cohesive soil consistency in working layer of the subgrade on the residual deformations of flexible pavement]. Abstract of a PhD thesis. Moscow: Izd-vo MADI, 2000. 20 p. (rus)

3. Zolotar I.A. K opredeleniyu ostatochnykh deformatsiy v dorozhnykh konstruktsiyakh pri mnogokratnykh dinamicheskikh vozdeistviyakh na nikh podvizhnykh transportnykh sredstv [On the estimation of residual deformations in road structures with repeated dynamic impact of transport vehicle]. Abstract of a PhD thesis. Saint–Petersburg: Izd-vo VATT, 1999. 31 p. (rus)

4. Kanygina S.Yu. Prognozirovaniye ostatochnykh deformatsiy dorozhnykh odezhd nezhestkogo tipa na zemlyanom polotne iz glinistykh gruntov [Forecasting of residual deformations of flexible pavement on the clay soil subgrade]. Abstract of a PhD thesis. Moscow: Izd-vo MADI, 1999. 20 p. (rus)

5. Fadeev V.B. Vliyaniye ostatochnykh deformatsiy grunta zemlyanogo polotna na koleyeobrazovaniye na proyezzhey chasti dorog s nezhestkimi dorozhnymi odezhdami [The impact of residual deformations of soil subgrade on rutting on the traffic area of the flexible pavement]. [Abstract of a PhD thesis. Moscow: Izd-vo MADI, 1999. 21 p. (rus)

6. VSN 46-72. Instruktsiya po proyektirovaniyu dorozhnykh odezhd nezhestkogo tipa [Military construction standards. Instructions for designing flexible pavement].Moscow: Transport, 1973. 110 p. (rus)

7. VSN 197-83. Instruktsiya po proyektirovaniyu zhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [Military construction standards. Instructions for designing rigid pavement]. Moscow: Mintransstroy, 1984. 129 p. (rus)

8. VSN 197-91. Instruktsiya po proyektirovaniyu zhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [Military construction standards. Instructions for designing rigid pavement].Moscow: Soyuzdornii, 1992. 130 p. (rus)

9. VSN 46-83. Instruktsiya po proyektirovaniyu dorozhnykh odezhd nezhestkogo tipa [Military construction standards. Instructions for designing flexible pavement].Moscow: Izd-vo Transport, 1985. 157 p. (rus)

10. Metodicheskiye rekomendatsii po proyektirovaniyu zhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [Guideline on designing rigid pavement]. Mintrans, 2003 (rus)

11. ODN 218-046-01. Proyektirovaniye nezhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [Trade road standards. Designing flexible pavement]. Moscow: GSDKh Mintransa Rossii, 2001. 146 p. (rus)

12. MODN 2-2001. Proyektirovaniye nezhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhd [Interstate trade road standards. Designing flexible pavement]. SoyuzDorNII, 2001. (rus)

13. Krivisskiy A.M. Printsipy naznacheniya konstruktsii dorozhnykh odezhd nezhestkogo tipa na magistralnykh avtomobilnykh dorogakh [Principles of fixing flexible pavement on primary roads]. Abstract of a PhD thesis. Leningrad: LISI, 1963. 31 p. (rus)

14. Sokolovskiy V.V. Statika sypuchei sredy [Granulated solids statics]. Moscow: Izd-vo fiziko-matematicheskoy literatury, 1960. 242 p. (rus)

15. GOST 12248-2010. Grunty. Metody laboratornogo opredeleniya kharakteristik prochnosti i deformi-ruemosti [National standard. Soil. Methods of laboratory determination of strength and deformability characteristics].

16. Semenova T.V., Gordeeva S.A., Gertsog V.N. Vestnik TGASU. 2012. No.4. Pp. 249–257. (rus)

17. SNiP 3.06.03-85. Avtomobilnyye dorogi [Standards and regulations in construction Highways]. (rus)

18. Smirnov A.V., Malyshev A.A., Agalakov Yu.A. Mekhanika ustoychivosti i razrusheniya dorozhnykh konstruktsiy [Stability and fracture mechanics of road structures]. Omsk: SibADI, 1997. 91p. (rus)

19. Aleksandrov A.S. Vestnik grazhdanskikh inzhenerov. 2008. No.4. Pp. 97–104.

20. Rekomendatsii po vyyavleniyu i ustraneniyu koley na nezhestkikh dorozhnykh odezhdakh: ODM [Recommendations on exposure and elimination of ruts on flexible pavement: trade road methodic]. Moscow: Rosavtodor, 2002. -179 p.

21. Aleksandrov A.S., Gordeeva S.A., Shpilko D.N. Avtomobilnaya promyshlennost. 2011. No.2. Pp. 31–35. (rus)

22. Aleksandrov A.S., Aleksandrova N.P., Semenova T.V. News of Higher Educational Institutions. Construction. 2009. No.2. Pp. 66–73. (rus)

23. Craig R.F. Soil Mechanics. London–New York: Taylor & Francis, 2004. 447 p.

24. Arnold G.K. Rutting of Granular Pavements. Thesis submitted to The University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, November 2004. 417 p.

25. Litvinskiy G.G. Analiticheskaya teoriya prochnosti gornykh porod i massivov [Analytic theory of strength of rock and solid mass]. Donetsk: Izd-vo Nord-Press, 2008. 207 p. (rus)

26. Goldenblat I.I., Knopov V.A. Kriterii prochnosti i plastichnosti konstruktsionnykh materialov [Strength and plasticity criterion of constructional materials]. Moscow: Mashinostroyeniye, 1968. 192 p. (rus)

27. Sdobyrev V.P. Izvestiya AN SSSR. Mekhanika i mashinostroyeniye. 1959. No.6. Pp. 93–99. (rus)

28. Potapova L.B., Yartsev V.P. Mekhanika materialov pri slozhnom napryazhennom sostoyanii. Kak prognoziruyut predelnyye napryazheniya? [Mechanics of materials in complex stressed state. How to forecast the ultimate stress?]. Moscow: Mashinostroyeniye-1, 2005. 244 p. (rus)

29. Pisarenko G.S., Lebedev A.A. Deformirovaniye i prochnost materialov pri slozhnom napryazhennom sostoyanii [Deformation of strength of materials in complex stressed state]. Kiev: Naukova Dumka, 1976. 416 p. (rus)

30. Drucker D.C., Prager W. Soil mechanics and plastic analysis of limit design. Quarterly of applied mechanics. 1952. Vol. 10. No.2. Pp. 157–165.

31. Roscoe K., Schofield A., Wroth C. On the yielding of soils. Geotechnique. 1958. Vol. 8. No.1. Pp. 22–53.

32. Roscoe K., Schofield A., Thurairajah A. Yielding of clays in state wetter than critical. Geotechnique. 1963. Vol. 13. No.3. Pp. 211–240.

33. Aleksandrov A.S., Dolgikh G.V., Kalinin A.L. Science & Engineering for Roads. 2012. No.2. Pp. 10–13. (rus)

34. Puzyrevskiy N.P. Teoriya napryazhennosti zemlistykh gruntov [Theory of earthy soil intensity]. Leningrad: Izd-vo LIIPS, 1929. 68 p. (rus)

35. Berezantsev V.G. Raschet prochnosti osnovaniy sooruzheniy [Calculation of strength of beses of structures]. Leningrad, 1960. 137 p. (rus)

36. Yaromko V.N. Science & Engineering for Roads. 2008. No.2. Pp. 28–32. (rus)

37. Badanin A.N., Bugrov A.K., Krotov A.V. Magazine of Civil Engineering. 2012. No.9. Pp. 29–34. (rus)

38. Kent M.F. AASHO road test vehicle operating costs related to gross weight. Highway Research Board Special Report 73. 1962. Pp. 149–165.

39. Sharp R.W., Booker J.R. Shakedown of Pavements under Moving Surface Loads. Journal of Transportation Engineering. ASCE. 1984. Vol. 110. No.1. Pp. 1–14.

40. Collins I.F., Cliffe P.F. Shakedown in frictional materials under moving surface loads. International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics. 1987. Vol. 11. No.4. Pp. 409–420.

41. Collins I.F., Wang A.P., Saunders L.R. Shakedown-Theory and the Design of Unbound Pavements. Australian Road Research Board, Road and Transport Research. 1993. Vol. 2. No.4. Pp. 28–37.

42. Aleksandrov A.S., Dolgikh G.V., Yuryev D.V. Transport Construction. 2011. No.7. Pp. 17–22. (rus)

43. Fedorovskiy V.G., Bezvolev S.G. Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering. 2000. No.4. Pp. 10–18. (rus)

44. Aleksandrov A.S., Aleksandrova N.P., Dolgikh G.V. Construction materials. 2012. No.10. Pp. 14–17. (rus).

Contact us Site map
All rights reserved. When using the information from this site the mention of the resource is obligatory